The End? The Beginning?
SaaS, Search, The Internet and AI?
## Editorial:
The End? The Beginning?
ServiceNow [lost almost 27%](https://www.trefis.com/stock/now/articles/621573/what-is-behind-the-move-in-servicenow-stock/2026-10-30) of its stock-market value on Thursday. Google’s parent, Alphabet, [fell 12.6%](https://apnews.com/article/1b5c71d31b4ce1e46b0db47b33141f6b) and [closed out its worst month ever](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/article/alphabets-october-wipeout-hits-766-billion-its-worst-month-ever-181407937.html). On Friday, Intel [fell about 29%](https://apnews.com/article/16c266731fdf64178f38070af2b42497), [its worst day since 1974](https://www.thestreet.com/stock-market-today/stock-market-today-dow-jones-sp-500-nasdaq-updates-oct-30-2026), and Reddit [lost more than a quarter of its value](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/article/reddit-pinterest-and-roblox-stocks-tank-after-q3-earnings-134009780.html) after beating every headline estimate. Roblox, Twilio and AMD also fell by double digits, and the Nasdaq [finished its worst month in over a year](https://www.cnn.com/2026/10/30/investing/us-stocks-ai-investment). These were different earnings stories, not a dozen identical collapses. But together they reveal a trend that reaches beyond this week’s share prices.
AI is succeeding and the businesses we expected to benefit are not the ones that are capturing its value.
Software becomes more useful while some software business models become less defensible. Finding answers becomes easier while the economics of search become harder. The internet enables more activity while the public websites through which we have experienced it lose their central position.
It is the beginning of something much larger. The consumption of the old way of doing things by the replacement we are all using more and more - AI.
### Software does not have to disappear
Software as a service succeeded by renting one product to thousands of customers and spreading the development cost across them.
AI changes the calculation. When making software becomes cheaper, more people can afford software designed around their own needs. A small team does not always need to adapt its work to a product built for a large market. Check out [SignalRank Intelligence ](https://intel.signalrank.ai)- entirely built using AI.
In [The End of the Internet](https://stratechery.com/2026/the-end-of-the-internet/), Ben Thompson describes private applications his team has built for podcast production, task tracking and calendars. They do not intend to sell them. Their value comes from being useful to the people who made them.
He calls the opportunity “smallness at scale.”
That is a market a conventional software company often could not serve profitably. It may now become a market people can serve for themselves.
I built my early tech career doing exactly this. My brother Brian and I built systems for Warner Brothers Music, Mobil Oil and others that were custom to their use cases. That custom experience is now available to anybody and close to free.
The scale is already visible. GitHub processed [7.4 billion commits in September](https://thenewstack.io/github-7-4b-commits-september/), a monthly figure that stood at 65 million in 2024, and attributes most of the growth to AI agents. Software is being made at a rate no SaaS vendor could have served.
Thompson’s argument has a second element. The retreat into smaller, trusted environments is also a security retreat, and this week supplied an example. Cohere caught an open-weight model [trying to upload data from its host](https://cohere.com/blog/concerning-behaviour-popular-open-weight-ai-model) to a cloud bucket in Beijing. Cheap software is also cheap attack surface, and that too pushes work behind closed doors. These are not rogue agents but rogue humans with more powerful tools.
None of this means every enterprise should replace its systems with a weekend coding project. Reliability, integration, security and responsibility still cost money. Nor is ServiceNow standing still: it reported 21% subscription revenue growth and is building tools to govern AI agents. But customers increasingly want work completed without navigating the software themselves. Suppliers will have to earn their place in that process, whether or not people still visit their screens.
### Search can improve while its economics weaken
Google faces a related problem. Its old bargain was to help us find somewhere else to go. Publishers supplied the destinations. Advertisers paid to appear along the journey. Many moons ago I predicted mobile would change the playing field of that opportunity. I was premature, Google has grown a lot since 2007. And they may do it again.
AI Mode removes the need for a journey to another site. That can be a better product. It can also remove opportunities to sell advertising and send traffic to publishers.
[Casey Newton explains the tension](https://www.platformer.news/thursday-newsletter-6/). Google’s search and related advertising revenue still grew 12% to $63.35 billion. This is not a business that has stopped working. But Google acknowledged that AI Mode monetizes less effectively than traditional search. The company is improving the experience while trying to rebuild the way it gets paid.
Publishers face the same transition from the other side. If readers no longer arrive, the economics of producing the material become harder. Newton argues that subscriptions and licensing may strengthen the largest platforms, which can afford access that smaller competitors cannot.
Reddit is this week’s clearest casualty. Revenue [grew 53% to $895 million](https://247wallst.com/investing/2026/10/30/reddit-plunges-25-as-search-traffic-slump-and-soft-outlook-overshadow-earnings-beat-snap-falls-5-pinterest-drops-4-meta-dips/), yet the stock lost a quarter of its value because Steve Huffman told investors that search referrals were [falling by more than a million a week](https://www.investing.com/news/transcripts/earnings-call-transcript-reddit-beats-q3-2026-estimates-but-stock-sinks-93CH-4985392) and guided below expectations for the fourth quarter. His explanation was blunt:
> “Web search is evolving from a gateway to the web to becoming an AI-powered destination itself.”
Reddit’s answer is to test a logged-in-only experience, which Huffman concedes means “trading reach for engagement.” A business can be more valuable to AI than ever and still lose the distribution that built it. I predict that will not work. Indeed what is needed is the opposite, remove friction to build reach and then upgrade the experience to drive engagement.
### The value has moved, not vanished
If the old businesses are losing value, where is it going? The answer arrived in the same week. Anthropic’s IPO filing reports [$16.3 billion of revenue](https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/1018476/anthropic-ipo-details-s1-filed-sec) in the first half of 2026, fourteen times the year before, and [net revenue retention near 900%](https://tomtunguz.com/anthropics-s1-grew-eleven-fold/). Its customers are using more of what it sells, not less. The value is not leaving software, search or the web. It is moving to the model layer and to whoever puts that layer to work.
That is the end and the beginning in a single week. ServiceNow, Alphabet and Reddit were repriced because the market can now see who captures the gains from cheaper intelligence.
### The larger opportunity is discovery (not web discovery)
The most interesting connection this week is between Thompson’s argument and [Noah Smith’s case for a golden age of science](https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/a-golden-age-of-science-is-coming).
Thompson describes software becoming economical for people whose needs were too small to attract a supplier. Smith describes research becoming possible on a scale that human researchers alone could not sustain. In both cases, the cost of doing intellectual work changes what is worth attempting.
His broadest predictions remain predictions. But we now have concrete work to examine.
[Anthropic’s drug-development report](https://www.anthropic.com/research/early-progress-drug-development) describes six research partnerships. At BigHat Biosciences, scientists used Claude to help improve antibody fragments, with about 1,010 variants made and tested over ten weeks. At Enveda, Claude-assisted checks of manufacturing documents reportedly reduced human review time by 89%.
The report is explicit: “All of this research is still at an early stage.” Most of it is preclinical. Better laboratory results and faster paperwork do not yet establish a treatment that works safely in people. But who would bet against AI making those breakthroughs on an accelerating timeline.
A second caveat. Anthropic’s own researchers found that professional analysts using Claude Code [adopted the agent’s hidden preferences 86% of the time](https://www.anthropic.com/research/agents-judgment-calls), and only 15% credited it. If separate laboratories inherit the same model’s assumptions, their agreement is not independent confirmation. A golden age of science needs scientists who still argue with their tools. In fact the tools are not as useful unless you argue with them.
[Venkatesh Rao’s Cognitive Mercantilism](https://contraptions.venkateshrao.com/p/cognitive-mercantilism) challenges the assumption that demand for intelligence is fixed. If we can do today’s work with less effort, it does not follow that we have run out of worthwhile things to do. People have ambitions they cannot currently afford to pursue.
That is a core belief for me. Less effort on today’s work frees effort for new work. We have diseases we cannot treat, products we cannot build and questions we have barely begun to ask. Making current work cheaper can expand those ambitions. It need not merely shrink the number of people employed on the old ones.
The week offered evidence. OpenAI and Anthropic have cut prices by [up to 80% within months](https://minimaxir.com/2026/10/cheap-llms/), and Tunguz observes that Anthropic’s revenue accelerated after its models became cheaper. Lower prices produced more demand, not less. Rao’s argument is visible in a company’s accounts.
### Smallness at scale meets capital at scale
Software is getting smaller. Venture capital is not. California startups have raised [$385 billion so far this year](https://news.crunchbase.com/venture/california-startups-most-us-funding-2026-openai-anthropic/), more than the whole country raised in any previous year, with OpenAI and Anthropic accounting for over half of it. [Series B dollars are up while the number of rounds is down](https://news.crunchbase.com/venture/seriesb-startup-funding-up-deals-down-ai-prometheus/), and rounds under $30 million have fallen from half the market to under a third. Third-quarter [Series A counts fell from 377 to 272](https://news.crunchbase.com/seed/jumbo-seriesa-squeeze-seed-startup-funding-schroder-mgv/).
That is concentration, not democratization. The tools to build a company have never been cheaper. The capital to scale one has rarely been harder to reach for anyone outside a few names. If smallness at scale is to produce new companies rather than only new private tools, the financing market needs a path for the modest round as well as the jumbo one. As I argued in reply to Martin Casado this week, access is part of the discipline of investing. Capital crowding into a handful of rounds is not access.
### The bills still have to be paid
[Jamin Ball’s reading of Anthropic’s filing](https://cloudedjudgement.substack.com/p/clouded-judgement-103026-dispelling) makes clear that we need to separate the wood and the trees when valuing it.
Large non-cash financing charges caused by equity grants are not the same as cash operating losses. Equally, today’s operating results do not yet provide enough to cover the cost of tomorrow’s computing commitments. Ball, whose employer is an investor, expects expansion to put renewed pressure on profitability.
### What is the market valuing?
Reddit and Roblox were punished for shrinking user counts, not shrinking revenue. Roblox beat expectations while [daily active users fell 9%](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/article/reddit-pinterest-and-roblox-stocks-tank-after-q3-earnings-134009780.html). If that pattern holds, the market is beginning to price attention rather than dollars, on the assumption that the dollars follow the attention with a lag.
An investor losing money does not establish that the technology failed society. It reflects that it is changing society and old investments make less sense.
The purpose of building AI capacity is to make the future. That will not preserve the market value of every company that preceded it. Indeed, the opposite is likely. The NASDAQ composite of 2036 will not look like 2026.
### What do we want to work on?
SaaS, search and the public web are ways we organized access to software and knowledge. But not forever.
The next stage will give more people the ability to act on their ideas. That means affordable intelligence, room for new companies, payment for valuable knowledge and a wider share in the wealth produced.
These goals require people to build them. The end of a familiar business model can be the beginning of an unfamiliar freedom. We should take the losses as a sign that the future is being born.
If more of us can build the tools we need and investigate the questions we care about, what will we choose to do that was previously beyond our reach? In my case - a lot.