Transcript Viewer

Democrats Need to Embrace AI

Nov 7, 2026 ยท 2026 #42. Read the transcript grouped by speaker, inspect word-level timecodes, and optionally turn subtitles on for direct video playback

Speaker Labels

Name the speakers

Edit labels for this show, save them in this browser, or download a JSON override for the production folder.

Transcript Playback

Democrats Need to Embrace AI

Human Transcript

Timed transcript

Blocks are grouped by speaker for readability. Expand a block to inspect word-level timing.

Speaker 1

Hey, welcome to That Was The Week. It is Friday, the 6th of November. Yeah, wow, already the 6th of November. It is almost 7 p.m. here in Palo Alto. And what a week, what a week. I'm about to go and watch Bill Maher on HBO, Real Time with Bill Maher, and I can't wait to see what he has to say about it. But this was the week that Trump, let's not, Let's not mince words, had his ass handed to him by millions of Americans who voted in very large numbers for his nemesis, the Democratic Party, in such a sweeping way that commentators really can't believe it. It looks like Mississippi is gonna fall or be one, which would put the cream on top of the cake And strangely, the stock market went up on Friday, sorry, not Friday, Wednesday, and then went down massively on Thursday. And it's pretty clear that the Thursday decline was the more meaningful of the two events. It reflected the stock market's assumption That the dividend from the AI boom, which is basically growth of gross domestic product, is going to slow or possibly stop. And that is probably rational. Clear view, I think it was this week in the newsletter, I talk about them, clean view. Estimate that something like 41% of commitments to data centers will suffer in one way or another from the new regimes, especially in Texas, by the way, which was a place that everyone was running towards, where the Democrats won handily, I will say. Now, I mean, on a personal level, I'm thrilled. I have very little time for Donald Trump or the Republican Party. On the other hand, I'm concerned because not a day went by until Bernie Sanders did a press conference talking about the need for a moratorium on data centers. And the key Democrat narrative in this election is about the need for wealth to be more evenly distributed. They focus on billionaires and trillionaires as the catchphrases, if you will, to talk about that. But their main point, which is that the disparity in the gap between the richest and the poorest is widening is completely true. The problem is they don't have a means of changing that. About as far as they can go is to talk about a wealth tax, which as I talk about in the editorial, wouldn't get even close to the amount of money required to fix this disparity. So especially at the levels they're talking about 5%, maybe if they talk about a 90% wealth tax, they might be getting close to it, but certainly a 5%, not even close. And I think a wealth tax is the wrong mechanism. What really would be required to change the way that wealth is distributed is quite simple, really. It's two things. Firstly, economic growth. The pie has to get bigger, bigger and bigger and bigger through productivity gains, preferably. And if the pie gets bigger, there's more to go around. So the first thing is the pie has to get bigger. And of course, AI is one of the key drivers of the pie getting bigger, it will drive enormous amounts of wealth, especially as the cost of labor comes down due to the fact that you won't need labor, a massive amounts of wealth are going to be produced, and low cost products are going to be available to everyone. So the cost of living ultimately will come down. So AI Is the ideal democratic instrument because it gives them the wealth they need to distribute, not just from individuals, but from growth and large amounts of growth. And then the second is you need a plan, a plan for distribution. Obviously, tax is part of that. Tax goes to government and government spends on health and education. I'm a strong believer in Syed's point of view that health should be free. To those who turn up in doctors or hospitals free, but that has to be paid for and wealth growth is how you pay for it. Not seizures or confiscations of wealth, but the growth of wealth is how you pay for it. You can also distribute via taxes, by taxing in more progressive ways, sure. But underlying it, you need growth. And then you need a plan. And there's some great examples in the world of how to distribute wealth. I think the best is Norway. What oil is to Norway, AI is to the whole world. And Norway took control of the wealth of oil and put it into a sovereign wealth fund. By the way, not the government. Key point, not the government. A sovereign wealth fund owned by all citizens That pays for infrastructure in Norway to the point where mostly the things you consume are free, education and health being two of them. And that idea of a wealth fund that owns the assets and that the wealth fund is owned by the people so that the assets benefit the people It's completely different to taxation. And it feels as if the Democrats could easily embrace within their umbrella the idea of equity in AI being owned by the people through a wealth fund, a human wealth fund, as I call it, because I don't want it to be just American, but a wealth fund. That seems to be something that we could all get behind. Certainly Anthropic has already donated 5% of its shares to a public benefit corporation that it owns. And that's planned to go to as high as 20%. OpenAI went further. It was originally a public benefit corporation that owned everything. It reorganized about a year ago, and 26% of OpenAI was owned at that point by its public benefit corporation. That's probably shrunk since then due to the fact that OpenAI has raised more money and sold more equity. But I'm not sure about that. I don't know how it's structured. It could be that it's still 26%. So those two... Let's think of them as gifts of equity to public benefit, already point in the direction that's obvious, and the Democrats should embrace it. Public benefit equity put into a wealth fund. Now, we should all own shares in the wealth fund. My proposal is we own one share each for our life. It goes away when we die. We can't transfer it. We can't sell it. So it's permanently... Owned by us for our life. And we get dividends as the wealth grows. We get dividends every year that are sufficient ultimately to pay for life. And that's very, very different to let's say universal basic income, which is considered like pensions, a kind of a benefit. This wouldn't be a benefit. It would be ownership, actual ownership through shares. In a wealth fund that itself owns the underlying assets to a large degree, preferably to a great degree. Anyway, I talk about that. I think this week's a great week to talk about it because the Democratic Party does not have a plan for growing and then distributing wealth that goes beyond confiscating Elon Musk money and people like Elon Musk. That seems to be insufficient On the face of it, to address the massive opportunity we've got to rethink everything in the light of AI. Think of the profound changes in education or in health, in the delivery of health that could come from AI. And as a progressive myself, I want to see progressives have a plan for that. Not talking about bans or moratoriums, but actually talking about ownership Growth and distribution of wealth. That's my two cents. I think it's the right time to have a conversation between now and January. And this is my contribution. So see you all next week. And thank you for reading That Was The Week. Hope you liked this week's articles.

Words and timings
Hey,welcometoThatWasTheWeek.ItisFriday,the6thofNovember.Yeah,wow,alreadythe6thofNovember.Itisalmost7p.m.hereinPaloAlto.Andwhataweek,whataweek.I'mabouttogoandwatchBillMaheronHBO,RealTimewithBillMaher,andIcan'twaittoseewhathehastosayaboutit.ButthiswastheweekthatTrump,let'snot,Let'snotmincewords,hadhisasshandedtohimbymillionsofAmericanswhovotedinverylargenumbersforhisnemesis,theDemocraticParty,insuchasweepingwaythatcommentatorsreallycan'tbelieveit.ItlookslikeMississippiisgonnafallorbeone,whichwouldputthecreamontopofthecakeAndstrangely,thestockmarketwentuponFriday,sorry,notFriday,Wednesday,andthenwentdownmassivelyonThursday.Andit'sprettyclearthattheThursdaydeclinewasthemoremeaningfulofthetwoevents.Itreflectedthestockmarket'sassumptionThatthedividendfromtheAIboom,whichisbasicallygrowthofgrossdomesticproduct,isgoingtosloworpossiblystop.Andthatisprobablyrational.Clearview,Ithinkitwasthisweekinthenewsletter,Italkaboutthem,cleanview.Estimatethatsomethinglike41%ofcommitmentstodatacenterswillsufferinonewayoranotherfromthenewregimes,especiallyinTexas,bytheway,whichwasaplacethateveryonewasrunningtowards,wheretheDemocratswonhandily,Iwillsay.Now,Imean,onapersonallevel,I'mthrilled.IhaveverylittletimeforDonaldTrumportheRepublicanParty.Ontheotherhand,I'mconcernedbecausenotadaywentbyuntilBernieSandersdidapressconferencetalkingabouttheneedforamoratoriumondatacenters.AndthekeyDemocratnarrativeinthiselectionisabouttheneedforwealthtobemoreevenlydistributed.Theyfocusonbillionairesandtrillionairesasthecatchphrases,ifyouwill,totalkaboutthat.Buttheirmainpoint,whichisthatthedisparityinthegapbetweentherichestandthepoorestiswideningiscompletelytrue.Theproblemistheydon'thaveameansofchangingthat.Aboutasfarastheycangoistotalkaboutawealthtax,whichasItalkaboutintheeditorial,wouldn'tgetevenclosetotheamountofmoneyrequiredtofixthisdisparity.Soespeciallyatthelevelsthey'retalkingabout5%,maybeiftheytalkabouta90%wealthtax,theymightbegettingclosetoit,butcertainlya5%,notevenclose.AndIthinkawealthtaxisthewrongmechanism.Whatreallywouldberequiredtochangethewaythatwealthisdistributedisquitesimple,really.It'stwothings.Firstly,economicgrowth.Thepiehastogetbigger,biggerandbiggerandbiggerthroughproductivitygains,preferably.Andifthepiegetsbigger,there'smoretogoaround.Sothefirstthingisthepiehastogetbigger.Andofcourse,AIisoneofthekeydriversofthepiegettingbigger,itwilldriveenormousamountsofwealth,especiallyasthecostoflaborcomesdownduetothefactthatyouwon'tneedlabor,amassiveamountsofwealtharegoingtobeproduced,andlowcostproductsaregoingtobeavailabletoeveryone.Sothecostoflivingultimatelywillcomedown.SoAIIstheidealdemocraticinstrumentbecauseitgivesthemthewealththeyneedtodistribute,notjustfromindividuals,butfromgrowthandlargeamountsofgrowth.Andthenthesecondisyouneedaplan,aplanfordistribution.Obviously,taxispartofthat.Taxgoestogovernmentandgovernmentspendsonhealthandeducation.I'mastrongbelieverinSyed'spointofviewthathealthshouldbefree.Tothosewhoturnupindoctorsorhospitalsfree,butthathastobepaidforandwealthgrowthishowyoupayforit.Notseizuresorconfiscationsofwealth,butthegrowthofwealthishowyoupayforit.Youcanalsodistributeviataxes,bytaxinginmoreprogressiveways,sure.Butunderlyingit,youneedgrowth.Andthenyouneedaplan.Andthere'ssomegreatexamplesintheworldofhowtodistributewealth.IthinkthebestisNorway.WhatoilistoNorway,AIistothewholeworld.AndNorwaytookcontrolofthewealthofoilandputitintoasovereignwealthfund.Bytheway,notthegovernment.Keypoint,notthegovernment.AsovereignwealthfundownedbyallcitizensThatpaysforinfrastructureinNorwaytothepointwheremostlythethingsyouconsumearefree,educationandhealthbeingtwoofthem.AndthatideaofawealthfundthatownstheassetsandthatthewealthfundisownedbythepeoplesothattheassetsbenefitthepeopleIt'scompletelydifferenttotaxation.AnditfeelsasiftheDemocratscouldeasilyembracewithintheirumbrellatheideaofequityinAIbeingownedbythepeoplethroughawealthfund,ahumanwealthfund,asIcallit,becauseIdon'twantittobejustAmerican,butawealthfund.Thatseemstobesomethingthatwecouldallgetbehind.CertainlyAnthropichasalreadydonated5%ofitssharestoapublicbenefitcorporationthatitowns.Andthat'splannedtogotoashighas20%.OpenAIwentfurther.Itwasoriginallyapublicbenefitcorporationthatownedeverything.Itreorganizedaboutayearago,and26%ofOpenAIwasownedatthatpointbyitspublicbenefitcorporation.That'sprobablyshrunksincethenduetothefactthatOpenAIhasraisedmoremoneyandsoldmoreequity.ButI'mnotsureaboutthat.Idon'tknowhowit'sstructured.Itcouldbethatit'sstill26%.Sothosetwo...Let'sthinkofthemasgiftsofequitytopublicbenefit,alreadypointinthedirectionthat'sobvious,andtheDemocratsshouldembraceit.Publicbenefitequityputintoawealthfund.Now,weshouldallownsharesinthewealthfund.Myproposalisweownoneshareeachforourlife.Itgoesawaywhenwedie.Wecan'ttransferit.Wecan'tsellit.Soit'spermanently...Ownedbyusforourlife.Andwegetdividendsasthewealthgrows.Wegetdividendseveryyearthataresufficientultimatelytopayforlife.Andthat'svery,verydifferenttolet'ssayuniversalbasicincome,whichisconsideredlikepensions,akindofabenefit.Thiswouldn'tbeabenefit.Itwouldbeownership,actualownershipthroughshares.Inawealthfundthatitselfownstheunderlyingassetstoalargedegree,preferablytoagreatdegree.Anyway,Italkaboutthat.Ithinkthisweek'sagreatweektotalkaboutitbecausetheDemocraticPartydoesnothaveaplanforgrowingandthendistributingwealththatgoesbeyondconfiscatingElonMuskmoneyandpeoplelikeElonMusk.ThatseemstobeinsufficientOnthefaceofit,toaddressthemassiveopportunitywe'vegottorethinkeverythinginthelightofAI.Thinkoftheprofoundchangesineducationorinhealth,inthedeliveryofhealththatcouldcomefromAI.Andasaprogressivemyself,Iwanttoseeprogressiveshaveaplanforthat.Nottalkingaboutbansormoratoriums,butactuallytalkingaboutownershipGrowthanddistributionofwealth.That'smytwocents.Ithinkit'stherighttimetohaveaconversationbetweennowandJanuary.Andthisismycontribution.Soseeyouallnextweek.AndthankyouforreadingThatWasTheWeek.Hopeyoulikedthisweek'sarticles.